Documentaries tv broadcasts gacaca process perpetrator confessions kwibuka conferences. Establish truth about what happened accelerate the legal proceedings for those accused of genocide. Truth, justice, and reconciliation in postconflict. Rwandas gacaca courts are hailed as a postgenocide success. Eyewitness to a genocide download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. The gacaca court system in the gacaca system, communities at the local level elected judges to hear the trials of genocide suspects accused of all crimes except planning of genocide. The gacaca courts, postgenocide justice and reconciliation in rwanda since 2001, the gacaca community courts have been the centrepiece of rwandas justice and reconciliation programme. Although loosely based on a traditional dispute resolution process, 1 the current gacaca is a statutory creation. Nearly every adult rwandan has participated in the trials, principally by providing eyewitness testimony concerning genocide crimes. In this article, we provide the first analysis of the outcomes of the gacaca courts, a traditional communitybased justice system that was greatly modified to address crimes of genocide. An analysis of the effectiveness of the gacaca court. The trials judged by the courts of appeals number 178,741, equivalent to 9% of the 1,958,634 cases judged by gacaca. Truth, justice, and reconciliation in postconflict rwanda. Inside rwandas gacaca courts seeking justice after genocide bert ingelaere.
A traditional rwandan system of justice in which local community members are allowed to testify freely, without the participation of lawyers, and cases. Journal of contemporary criminal justice genocide, justice. Jean kayigamba reports on some mixed feelings about how effectively these courts have been able to bring about real justice. Therefore, the government of rwanda has proposed using the \ gacaca \ traditional courts to accelerate postgenocide justice. From the outset, most international observers fiercely opposed the use of gacaca for trying genocide crimes. Jun 18, 2012 the courts were set up to speed up the prosecution of hundreds of thousands of genocide suspects awaiting trial. The legacy of rwandas communitybased gacaca courts hrw. Nonetheless, there is no doubt that the gacaca courts are a mechanism with which the majority of the rwandan population, hutu and tutsi. Two systems of retributive justice were set up by the international community and the rwandan government to try suspects of the 1994 genocide. Due to the nationwide presence of gacaca courts it is assumed that a large number of rwandans participated in the trials, either as victims, perpetrators, witnesses or spectators clark, 2008, pp. Rwanda gacaca genocide courts finish work bbc news. An analysis of the effectiveness of the gacaca court system. The first phase, which began in 1997 and is still continuing, targets the most serious offenders. This article argues that the seeming lack of consensus does not signal the impossibility of adequately representing the gacaca courts.
Ogot book prize, sponsored by the african studies association. An alternative solution for postgenocide justice and national reconciliation gerald butera captain, rwandan army b. The norwegian helsinki committee has since early 1990s promoted accountability for crimes against humanity and war crimes in the wars of the former yugoslavia and in other conflict areas within the osce region. In february 1999, when the rwandan government was still debating the possibility of adapting gacaca to meet its needs, the united nations office of the high commissioner for human rights ohchr argued vehemently that communitybased courts were illequipped to handle complex genocide. Gacaca process post genocide reconciliation this paper has a twofold objective.
Combining both legal and empirical research, this book explores the statutory aspects and practice of gacaca courts inkiko gacaca, the centrepiece of rwandas postgenocide transitional justice system, assessing their contribution to truth, justice and reconciliation. The aim of the interviews was to learn more about how testifying in such a public event as the gacaca affects psychological health. The traditional community gacaca courts set up to prosecute the perpetrators of the 1994 rwandan genocide will be closing this month. Organic law n 0 402000 of 26012001 setting up and organizing prosecutions for offences constituting the crime of genocide or crimes against humanity committed between october 1, 1990 and december 31, 1994. Rwandas gacaca courts were established as a response to the backlog of untried genocide cases. The work was carried out with support from the belgian. This traditional, communal justice was adapted in 2001 to fit the needs of rwanda in the wake of the 1994 rwandan genocide where over an estimated 1,000,000 people were killed, tortured and raped. Final monitoring and research report on the gacaca process september 2009 marked the end of an era for rwanda and also for pri.
In an earlier survey,53 percent of respondents said they were highly confident that gacacawould promote a lasting peace ballabola 2001. May 31, 2011 human rights watch also documented cases where gacaca courts ordered the detention of accused persons or witnesses without establishing that the person intended to flee or might cause harm to. The gacaca courts generated valuable information about the genocide suspects and increased access to the justice system. Number of trials judged by gacaca courts of appeals. Tilburg university the legacy of the gacaca courts in. Administrative report on gacaca from the national service of gacaca courts.
This traditional, communal justice was adapted in 2001 to fit the needs of rwanda in the wake of the 1994 rwandan genocide where over an estimated. Looking at the mandate of the courts, the public nature of the courts, the composition of the courts, and the security of participants of the courts, we conclude that gacaca courts could have had a bigger impact on reconciliation. Jun 15, 2012 the traditional community gacaca courts set up to prosecute the perpetrators of the 1994 rwandan genocide will be closing this month. Although gacaca has brought more people to trial than the ictr, transnational trials, and the ordinary rwandan courts combined, gacaca exposesand perhaps deepensconflict, resentment, and. Rwandas gacaca courts provide an innovative response to the genocide of 1994. Pdf in 1994, over a million tutsi and moderate hutu were brutally killed in rwanda during a threemonthlong genocide. In this contribution, the legacy of the gacaca courts is studied by looking at what the gacaca courts have achieved or may not have achieved against the objectives it was set up for in the rst place from the per spective of genocide survivors. In february 1999, when the rwandan government was still debating the possibility of adapting gacaca to meet its needs, the united nations office of the high commissioner for human rights ohchr argued vehemently that communitybased courts were illequipped to handle complex. A collection of quotes about the gacaca court system in. Bert ingelaere, based on his observation of two thousand gacaca trials, offers a comprehensive assessment of what these courts set out to do. Despite its restorative practices and character, gacaca remains a legal process wielenga and harris 2011. This article does not dwell on the crisis of representation. Gacaca courts in rwanda charges against the gacaca despite the governments aspirations for the gacaca process, some prominent ngos have contended that the system is fundamentally. Nearly every adult rwandan has participated in the trials, principally by providing eyewitness testimony concerning.
Human rights watch also documented cases where gacaca courts ordered the detention of accused persons or witnesses without establishing. Available to download in english here, kinyarwanda here and french here. Global tides volume 8 article 4 112014 an analysis of the effectiveness of the gacaca court system in postgenocide rwanda lauren haberstock pepperdine university, lauren. However, a person can be linked to multiple cases hence the reason why there are more cases than individuals. Although some survey data from this study show strong popular support for gacaca and the project of reconciliation, and although there appear to be some positive social trends in the community. Amnesty international has argued, any criminal justice system, no ma 4 er what its form, would lose credibility without an adherence to international. The gacaca system and the international criminal tribunal.
Rwandas gacaca courts were established as a response to the backlog of untried. Eyewitness to genocide download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Genocide trials and gacaca courts journal of international. Although gacaca has brought more people to trial than the ictr, transnational trials, and the ordinary rwandan courts combined, gacaca exposesand perhaps deepensconflict, resentment, and ethnic disunity. After years of recording and supporting a greater understanding of the gacaca jurisdictions, pris monitoring and research programme came to a close as the government of rwanda wound up this system of communitybased courts for prosecuting genocide suspects. The gacaca court consists of a general assembly, a bench and a coordinating committee. After years of recording and supporting a greater understanding of the gacaca jurisdictions, pris monitoring and research programme came to a close as the government of rwanda wound up this system of communitybased. The gacaca courts and south african truth and reconciliation commission it can hardly be denied that the justice system, in its highly bureaucratic form, is seen as one of the defining features of western society.
Report title publication date gacaca jurisdictions and their preparations january 2002 research on the gacaca july 2002 the guilty plea procedure, cornerstone of the. They also have suggested innovative ideas for improving the gacaca process, exploring a range of methods to ensure fair dispensation of justice and greater public acceptance. The purpose of this thesis is to determine whether, and under what conditions, the gacaca courts can be an effective mechanism of justice and national reconciliation. Jul 02, 2010 the gacaca courts have proved to be the answer. The focus will be on gacaca courts which present a traditional and domestic tool of retributive and restorative justice. Rwandas gacaca courts are hailed as a postgenocide. The objectives of the gacaca court were the following. Whilst perpetrators are indeed sentenced to some form of punishment, it is important to note that this seldom takes the form of a jail sentence. Gacaca courts date back to before rwanda was colonized bornkamm, 2012. The introduction of the gacaca courts improved the performance of the formal justice system and facilitated postconflict recovery. Gacaca, the local courts in rwanda, o cially closed on 18 june 2012.
The general assembly at the cell level is made up of all inhabitants aged 18 years or more. Gacaca courts and restorative justice in rwanda thomas hauschildt, jul 15 2012, 12176 views. Rwandas gacaca courts paul christoph bornkamm oxford. Since 2001, the gacaca community courts have been the centrepiece of rwandas justice and reconciliation programme. The system dealt mainly with civil and social conflicts between members of the community. The gacaca courts, postgenocide justice and reconciliation in rwanda. Gacaca courts originate from the traditional system of conflict resolution called gacaca. The difficult path to peace in the wake of horrific crimes. Watch videos of the gacaca courts which processed 1. A collection of quotes about the gacaca court system in post genocide rwanda. The volume expands the knowledge regarding these courts, assessing not only their performance in terms of formal justice and. Incorporating elements of both african dispute resolution and of westernstyle criminal courts, gacaca courts are in line with recent trends to revive traditional grassroots mechanisms as a way of addressing a violent past.
A normativeethical perspective dadimos haile 1 january 2008 1 ll. Rwandas experiment in peoples courts gacaca and the. The introduction of the gacaca courts improved the performance of the formal justice system and facilitated post. Gacaca how rwanda judged its genocide by phil clark. For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription. Traditional justice and reconciliation after violent conflict. Gacaca courts free download as powerpoint presentation. The gacaca system and the international criminal tribunal for. The courts were set up to speed up the prosecution of hundreds of thousands of genocide suspects awaiting trial.
The publications on the modernized gacaca courts dealing with the legacy of the rwandan genocide are abundant and they often seem to be rife with diverging analysis and conclusions. Courts gacaca and the tragedy of unexamined humanitarianism. Karegeya talks about his involvement in the 1994 genocide against tutsi. Following the genocide, in 1994, the minister of justice proposed that gacaca be revived in order to relieve the struggling judicial system of the burden of. The number of suspects to be tried in connection with the genocide was immense, and cases moved slowly through the ictr and national courts. Human rights group say the gacaca fell well short of international legal standards. D duke university school of law, 2006 the author wishes to thank professor philip reyntjens and mrs. Final monitoring and research report on the gacaca process. Lawyers are banned from any official involvement, an issue that has generated sustained criticism from human rights organisations and. Genocide, justice, and rwandas gacaca courts hollie nyseth. In 2001, in an attempt to clear the backlog of some 115,000 genocide cases awaiting trial, the rwandan government. An analysis of the effectiveness of the gacaca court system in postgenocide rwanda lauren haberstock pepperdine university, lauren. Gacaca definition of gacaca by the free dictionary. Carter introduction the gacaca proceedings in rwanda are an innovative and unique response to a postconflict situation.
This article presents unique material from indepth interviews with 16 women in rwanda who have testified in the gacaca, the village tribunals initiated to enhance reconciliation after the 1994 genocide. Jul 15, 2012 the focus will be on gacaca courts which present a traditional and domestic tool of retributive and restorative justice. September 2009 marked the end of an era for rwanda and also for pri. This split within the human rights community has important implications not only for the e. The road to reconciliation in rwanda the role of gacaca. May 04, 2014 the national service of the gacaca courts snjg, the overseeing government body, communicated following a closing ceremony in 2012 that 1,003,227 individuals stood trial during the 7 years that gacaca was operational. Schabas abstract after many decades of impunity, rwanda has embarked upon a course of transitional justice committed to prosecuting all who are suspected of involvement in the 1994 genocide. We feel we should run faster, and get this country to greater heights says the chief of police, there is quite a lot we missed during the.
459 1684 1599 870 598 1111 1084 214 15 1192 1109 1013 1523 294 1588 1585 1664 22 499 139 22 1522 1367 1129 650 202 405 861 615 1375 14 808 383 1162 1103 1043 59 156